By The Bucket Surprise Gallery Menu
- All Popular Dises
Entrées
DEALS
Caesar Salads
Sides
Dessert
Drinks
Large Bucket
1.5 lbs of Spaghetti w/Marinara Sauce (Pick Meat Sauce for an additional charge) 1/2 Loaf of Toasted Garlic Bread. Meatballs sold separately. Feeds 4-5
$23.95
Medium Bucket
1 lb. of Spaghetti w/Marinara Sauce (Pick Meat Sauce for an additional charge) 1/4 loaf of Toasted Garlic Bread. Meatballs sold separately. Feeds 2-3
$17.95
Small Bucket
1/2 lb. Spaghetti w/Marinara Sauce (Pick Meat Sauce for an additional charge) Three Pieces of Toasted Garlic Bread. Meatballs sold separately. Feeds 1-2
$11.95
Chopped Lunch Combo
1/2 lb of Spaghetti with 12 oz of Meat Sauce - chopped and ready to enjoy with 3 Pieces of Toasted Garlic Bread and a 20 oz beverage!
$14.95
Meatball
2 oz. of Perfection! Pork, Beef, Ricotta and Romano cheese.
$2.25
Italian Sausage Link
Delicious 4 oz Mild Italian Sausage Link
$4.50
Meatball Sub
This hot submarine style sandwich – it’s meaty, saucy and cheesy! 3 Meatballs - Covered with Marinara Sauce and Boar's Head Cheese.
$12.95
Italian Sausage Sub
4 oz Mild Italian Sausage Link on an 8" Hoagie Roll Smothered in Marinara Sauce and Covered with Mozzarella Cheese
$12.95
Family Deal
Large Bucket w/ Marinara Sauce (Pick Meat Sauce for an additional charge) 5 Meatballs: Pork/Beef/Ricotta & Romano Cheese Full Loaf of Toasted Garlic Bread Feeds 4-5
$35.95
Ultimate Family Deal
Large Bucket w/Marinara sauce (Pick Meat Sauce for an additional charge) 7 Meatballs: Pork/Beef/Ricotta & Romano Cheese Full Loaf of toasted Garlic Bread Large Caesar Salad 8 oz side of Marinara Sauce (Pick Meat Sauce for an additional charge) Feeds 4-5
$47.95
Party Pack
2 Large Buckets w/Marinara Sauce (Choose Meat Sauce for 1 or Both Buckets for additional charge) 12 Meatballs; 2 Full Loaves of Garlic Bread 2 Large Caesar Salads; a 2 Liter Pepsi Product Feeds 10 - 12
$89.95
Large Caesar Salad
8 oz of Crispy Romaine Lettuce Shaved Parmesan Cheese Toasted Croutons Creamy Caesar Dressing on the side
$9.95
Small Caesar Salad
5 oz of Crispy Romaine Lettuce Shaved Parmesan Cheese Toasted Croutons Creamy Caesar Dressing on the side
$6.95
Full Loaf Garlic Bread
A Delicious Full Loaf of Garlic Bread Toasted to Order.
$7.95
Cheesy Bread 1/2 Loaf
1/2 Loaf of Toasted Garlic Bread Smothered with Mozzarella Cheese!
$7.95
Garlic Pizza Bread
1/4 loaf of our toasted Garlic Bread covered with Marinara Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese. Served traditional or add sliced Meatball or Sliced Italian Sausage
$9.95
Extra Marinara Sauce
8 oz of our Tasty Marinara Sauce!
$3.00
Extra Meat Sauce
8 oz of our delicious Meat Sauce
$4.00
Cheesecake
Try a Slice of our New York style Cheesecake!
$4.95
20oz Pepsi Products
$2.50
2 Liter Pepsi Products
Choose from pepsi; diet pepsi; or mountain dew
$4.00
Pure Leaf Unsweetened Tea 18.5oz
Unsweetened brewed pure leaf tea
$2.50
Rock Star Energy Drink 16oz
Original
$3.00
If you’re in the mood for some seriously satisfying comfort food, the By The Bucket Surprise Menu is a feast that doesn’t hold back. Imagine digging into crispy, golden chicken that’s juicy on the inside, paired with sides that hit all the right notes-from buttery mashed potatoes to seasoned fries that keep you reaching for more. Every bucket feels like a surprise in the best way, letting you mix and match flavors and portions to suit your cravings. Whether you’re sharing with friends, fueling up for a big game, or just treating yourself after a long day, this menu makes it easy to indulge without overthinking. Plus, the variety keeps every visit interesting; you’ll find classic favorites alongside creative twists that make each bite a little adventure. And don’t forget about the sauces-each one adds a punch, letting you customize every mouthful exactly how you like it. By the time you’re done, it’s clear that this menu isn’t just about filling up-it’s about enjoying every single moment of it.